| Treasurer's Name |
Years |
| W.M. George |
1872-1875 |
| T.M. Helm |
1875-1879 |
| W.J. Byers |
1879-1982 |
| Lair Dean |
1882 |
| John Johnson |
1883-1885 |
| Adam Shoemaker |
1885-1888 |
| Theo. Shoemaker |
1888 |
| Tim Woods |
1889 |
| J.H. Johnston |
1889-1891 |
| John M. Allen |
1891-1985 |
| S.M. Crook |
1895-1899 |
| S.L. Manker |
1899-1903 |
| Henry A. Myers |
1903-1907 |
| I.S. McCormick |
1907-1911 |
| F.S. Munsinger |
1911-1915 |
| Chas. Buell |
1915-1919 |
| Duane Wolfe |
1919-1923 |
| Geo. A. Hammond |
1923-1925 |
| R.H. Stones |
1925-1927 |
| Mabel Workman |
1927-1931 |
| Harry Kite |
1931-1935 |
| Luella Rorabaugh |
1935-1937 |
| Leo Shook |
1937-1941 |
| Clarence Holmes |
1941-1945 |
| Edna Clark |
1945-1947 |
| Clarence Holmes |
1947-1951 |
| Zona Small |
1951-1955 |
| Marie Belle Sims |
1955-1959 |
| Ila Holmes |
1959-1963 |
| Margaret Ayers |
1963-1967 |
| Donald Lambert |
1967-1981 |
| Harry Jones III |
1981-1999 |
| Mark E. Schemm |
1999-2012 |
